Why My Mother-in-law Trusts FDs More Than Me
Blog · Family Money
Why My Mother-in-law Trusts FDs More Than Me
By Arvind Kumar Sharma · AMFI-Registered Mutual Fund Distributor (ARN 366858)
I am, technically, a AMFI-registered professional who thinks about investing for a living. None of that has ever once outweighed a fixed deposit receipt in my mother-in-law's eyes. And honestly, the more I've sat with why, the less I think she's being unreasonable.
A Trust Built Over Decades, Not Undone by One Conversation
Her relationship with the bank FD isn't really about interest rates. It's a relationship built over forty-plus years of walking into a branch, filling a form by hand, and walking out with a piece of paper that says exactly what she'll get, and exactly when. No app, no chart, no fine print about "market risk." Just a promise, printed and dated. That kind of trust doesn't get replaced by a son-in-law's PowerPoint, however well-intentioned.
Why FDs Feel Safe to Her Generation
Her generation came of age watching a stock market that, more than once, gave people real reasons to be cautious — the Harshad Mehta scandal in 1992, the Ketan Parekh episode almost a decade later. Those weren't abstract headlines to her; they were the reason "shares" became a word associated with risk and scandal at her family's dinner table for years afterward. An FD, by comparison, never made the news for the wrong reasons.
Where She's Not Wrong
I try not to argue with the parts of this that are genuinely true, because there are several:
- The return is fixed and known in advance — no surprises, no volatility to watch
- Deposits up to ₹5 lakh per depositor, per bank, are protected under DICGC insurance
- Simple to open, simple to understand, no ongoing decisions required
- Genuinely well-suited to money you'll need soon, or can't afford to see dip
- FD interest is fully taxable, and current rates often sit close to or below inflation
- A rupee left purely in FDs for 20+ years can lose real purchasing power over time
- Equity-oriented funds have historically offered stronger long-term growth potential
- Best suited to goals that are years away, not money needed next month
I've stopped trying to convince her FDs are the wrong choice. They aren't. I just try to show her they don't have to be the only choice.
What I Actually Suggest at Home
Her FDs stay exactly where they are — untouched, unquestioned, doing the job she trusts them to do for money she wants to see protected. Alongside that, for the newer, longer-horizon goals in the family, we've slowly started small SIPs — not as a replacement for what she trusts, but as a second habit running quietly next to it. Nobody's savings account got raided to prove a point.
Earning It, Slowly
I don't think I'll ever fully win this argument, and I've made peace with that. What's actually changed, a few years in, is smaller and better than winning: she now asks how the SIP is doing, unprompted, over dinner. That's not a convert. That's just curiosity, which is usually where real trust actually starts.
This account has been shared in a light, personal tone and reflects one family's experience rather than universal advice. FD interest rates vary by bank and change periodically; figures and comparisons here are general in nature. This article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks. Please read all scheme-related documents carefully before investing.